It’s happened to the best of us. We let Mr. Right slip through our fingers, and we’re left wondering what might have been. The memories we could have made together, the touchdowns we could have scored, the three pointers, the championships… What were we thinking? How did we let you get away? I’m talking, of course, about athletes.
As the 1978 NBA season was winding down a deal was in the works between NBA Lawyer David Stern, Buffalo Braves owner John Y. Brown, and Boston Celtics owner Irv Levin. Going into the season, the Braves did not meet attendance expectations, selling less than 4,500 season tickets, which resulted in the franchise receiving an escape clause in their lease. In Boston, Levin, a California businessman, was set on moving his team to the golden state. But, of course, the NBA would never allow their cornerstone franchise, one of the greatest dynasties in basketball history, to leave Bean Town. So what to do?
Stern proposed a swap. Levin takes the Braves. Brown takes the Celtics. Straight up. Well, sort of. Also, as part of the deal, the Celts received Tiny Archibald (who had missed the 1977/78 season with an Achilles tendon injury), Billy Knight, and Marvin Barnes. The Braves received Freeman Williams, back-up center Kevin Kunnert, and power forwards Kermit Washington and Sidney Wicks. No draft picks were requested in the deal, which allowed Boston to retain the draft rights to Larry Bird, the number six choice overall in the 1978 NBA draft.
It didn’t really matter anyway though, did it? I mean, the Braves, now the Clippers, were already in San Diego and finished the 1978/79 season with a winning record, 43-39, nine games back of that season’s NBA champion Seattle SuperSonics. The Celtics finished 25 games back, dead last in the Atlantic Division of the Eastern Conference. Oh, and that draft pick, Bird I think it was? He decided to stay at Indiana State and play his senior season in college anyway, not entering the NBA until 1979, when he became the league’s Rookie of the Year narrowly beating out his longtime rival Earvin “Magic” Johnson. Larry Legend went on to become one of the NBA’s 50 greatest players, winning three NBA championships with the Celtics, and was inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in 1998.
Of course Bird would have never played as a Brave. Hell, he probably would have tacked on a post-graduate year at Indiana State had he been drafted by Buffalo, but the deal was already done making that an impossibility regardless. The reality is: the closest the Queen City would have ever come to sharing in the glory of Larry “Legend” Bird would have been as posthumous Buffalo Braves fans, three thousand miles away watching on television as the San Diego Clippers struggled through season after NBA season.
Buffalo is a football town anyway, and the Bills would never let “the one” get away, right? The 1990 NFL draft saw the number 16 and 17 picks go to Buffalo and Dallas, respectively. The Bills selected James Williams, a defensive back from Fresno State, who became most famous for being the first Buffalo player to wear the number 31 jersey (it had formerly been retired as being representative of “the spirit of the Bills”). With the 17th pick in the NFL draft, the Dallas Cowboys selected Emmitt Smith, running back from the University of Florida.
By 1990, Thurman Thomas, the Bills’ running back, was posting career numbers after being drafted in the second round in 1988. In fact, he ended up leading the AFC in rushing in 1990, ‘91, and ‘93. In 1990 though, he almost led Buffalo to their first ever Super Bowl win rushing for 135 yards, one touchdown and catching five passes for 55 yards. There was even talk of Super Bowl XXV MVP honors going to Thomas even though the Bills had lost the game to the New York Giants 20-19.
In 1991, Thomas was named NFL most valuable player while he helped lead his team to a second straight championship game, Super Bowl XXVI, where the Bills were defeated by the Washington Redskins. In 1992, the Bills found themselves in a third straight Super Bowl, where, ironically, they met the Dallas Cowboys. Before the game, Thomas put his helmet on the 40 yard line, a pre-game ritual, lost track of it during the National Anthem subsequently resulting in his absence from the first two offensive series for the Bills (Kenneth Davis botched a handoff on the first series), and the Bills were trounced by Emmitt Smith and the Cowboys 17-52. The next year, Buffalo and Dallas met again in Super Bowl XXVII. Thomas only produced 19 yards rushing, though he did retain his helmet’s whereabouts throughout the pre-game festivities, a moral victory nonetheless. Dallas won the game 30-13, and Emmitt Smith took MVP honors.
Thurman Thomas was arguably the greatest running back in Buffalo Bills history (O.J. Simpson did not have the offensive line to support him early in his career, though he was the first player in NFL history to break the 2,000-yard single season rushing mark in 1973 with 2,003 yards). Thomas, though, rushed the Bills to an unprecedented four consecutive Super Bowl appearances. Though he never got the Bills over the hump, he gave Buffalo something to cheer about throughout most of the nineties.
Emmitt Smith finished his career with three Super Bowl rings, one Super Bowl MVP award, a league MVP award in ‘93, and he was named offensive rookie of the year in 1990. Smith was a postseason juggernaut who amassed 1,586 yards, 19 touchdowns, 7 consecutive 100-yard games, and 9 straight games with a touchdown. An impressive resume no doubt, but the one postseason record he does not stand alone on, total playoff touchdowns (21), he shares with Thurman Thomas.
Hindsight is 20/20. Who knows what Smith would have done as a Buffalo Bill? Would we be the three or four or five-time Super Bowl champs? Or would Smith’s talents have been wasted as a backup to Thomas’ already impressive resume? Was the trio of Aikman, Irvin, and Smith truly that much more potent than that of Kelly, Reed, and Thomas? Super Bowl history leans toward yes, but oh, what might have been?
Probably closest to our hearts and minds, at least those of us who attended St. Bonaventure University, is the Bonnies basketball career of Mike Gansey, a six-foot four mop-haired all-purpose shooting guard from Ohio. In two seasons (2001-2003), Gansey quickly became the future of Bonnies basketball. The Bonnies’ great white hope, if you will. A new kind of guard, a scrapper, to fill the void of losing Caswell Cyrus, David Messiah Capers, and Tim Winn, all integral members of the 2000 squad’s NCAA tournament birth (the team lost in a double-overtime first round game to Tayshaun Prince and the Kentucky Wildcats). Mostly a bench player as a freshman, Gansey became a starter in his sophomore season averaging 13.9 points, 5.0 rebounds, and shooting over 40% from three-point range.
And then there was the scandal. In 2003, St. Bonaventure’s basketball program was rocked by the involvement of the university’s president, athletic director, and men’s basketball coach in the forging of credentials of transfer center Jamil Terrell. Terrell was admitted to St. Bonaventure University with only a welding certificate from Coastal Georgia Community College. He was forced to leave the team. Athletic Director Gothard Lane, president Robert Wickenheiser, and coach Jan van Breda Kolff were either dismissed or resigned. With them, so went Gansey.
Gansey transferred to the University of West Virginia where he continued to be a hustling crowd pleaser after sitting out the 2003/04 season as stipulated in transfer player rules. In just two seasons, Gansey “had the 18th highest career scoring average (14.35), the ninth best field goal percentage in a career (52.6%), the third best 3-point field goal percentage in a career (39.4%), the seventh most steals per game in a career (1.75) and the 12th most minutes per game in a career (32.12)” for the Mountaineers. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Gansey).
Perhaps Gansey was the only athlete that Western New York ever really had a shot at truly loving. After all, he was ours, if only for a short time. Larry Bird was just a fantasy. And Emmitt Smith could have broken our hearts just as easily as any other running back. Besides, Thurman Thomas gave us some of the best years of our lives. We cannot change the past, dwelling on what might have been, but we can always be grateful for what we had.
JHurls
The Niceness